Controversial Scrutiny by Sensitivity Readers

Curious about how to make a story resonate with diverse readers? It's getting more crucial as we welcome an increasing number of perspectives.

First things first: before you hop onto the keyboard, heed this: sensitivity readers are your new best friends. They're like those grammar gurus that ensure your sentences make sense, but for the human experiences essential to storytelling.

So, what's the deal with sensitivity readers? Think of them as your culture saviors in the publishing world. They're individuals with real-world experiences in various areas like the LGBTQ+ community, mental health struggles, cultural groups, and more. They'll feast their eyes on your manuscript, sniffing out anything offensive, inaccurate, or stereotypical.

Working on a novel about the LGBTQ+ community but don't belong to it yourself? No sweat! A sensitivity reader who does will be there to ensure your portrayal is on-point and respectful. They're like superpowers for those of us not in the know!

These GMs of the writing world help authors create stories that feel authentic and inclusive. While some focus on providing feedback, others offer additional services like editorial assistance or fact-checking. The goal always remains the same: boosting the inclusivity and quality of the work.

How sensitivity readers work:

Catch them after the developmental edits. The ideal timing depends on your story. For instance, if your plot involves characters from different ethnic backgrounds, their feedback could focus on characterization, dialogue, and perspective, which can be tackled during later editing stages. However, if race is a central conflict, collaborate with a sensitivity reader earlier on. Some creative spirits even bring sensitivity readers into the plotting phase to gather early feedback on their story's overall direction.

Keep in mind: sensitivity readers often have a long to-read list, so plan ahead and book them as early as possible. Once they've devoured your manuscript, they'll deliver a feedback report outlining their suggestions and concerns.

Many sensitivity readers specialize in specific areas, boasting expertise within particular identities and experiences. As British Columbia editor and author Kimberly Vanderhorst pointed out, "We are highly specialized developmental editors focused on character identity. We bring extra authenticity to a writer's work. We help them with vocabulary and identify harmful stereotypes that we've had to face in our lives so they don't put those into their books."

One sensitivity reader is gold, but having several can provide a more comprehensive grasp of potential issues. As Travis Croken declared, "When you get a sensitivity reader, it's not just one person that is holding the weight of the community on their shoulders. You should have multiple sensitivity readers looking at it."

Expertise offered:

Worried about their credibility? Sensitive readers possess a big plus – real-life experience. They know the ropes of the issues they're addressing.

As Canadian author Travis Croken explained, "They don't have to have a PhD in whatever community they're with, but it's someone who's gone through part of the experience of what you're trying to represent."

Why hire them?

There are a million reasons to bring sensitivity readers aboard, but we'll cover a few standouts:

A. If you're writing:

If your central character belongs to the LGBTQIA2S+ community and you don't
If your character experiences mental health challenges you haven't
If your character is part of an ethnic community you're not a part of
If your character is a different race than you
If your character has a disability and you don't
If your character has a backstory or central conflict involving traumatic experiences you're unfamiliar with

Sensitivity readers are invaluable for enhancing character authenticity, combating unconscious bias, and promoting inclusive storytelling.

B. If you're a publisher:

With sensitivity readers, you'll nail historical and cultural accuracy and avoid perpetuating harmful stereotypes. You'll also lower the risk of public backlash over insensitive content, saving your reputation from potential damage.

The demand for sensitivity readers continues to grow due to a rising awareness of the importance of representation and inclusivity in storytelling, as well as concerns about unwanted backlash. In children's and young adult literature, publishers often turn to sensitivity readers to ensure their books are both accurate and tactful.

While some critics argue that sensitivity readers can stifle creativity or lead to excessive caution, many in the industry see them as essential partners in the publishing process. Remember: sensitivity readers can't guarantee complete immunity from criticism, but they will significantly reduce the risk of negative feedback. See them as collaborators in the editing process rather than obstacles.

Working with sensitivity readers:

Navigating the sensitivity reader relationship can feel a little tricky, but here are a few tips to help you build a successful partnership:

Embrace discomfort: Whenever someone sends you feedback about aspects you had initially overlooked, remember: discomfort is the sign of learning. It's better to identify a problem now and address it rather than publishing something offensive later.
Prioritize openness: Sensitivity readers are professionals who want to help you write a great story. Remind yourself that they're on your side, not out to judge you for omissions.
Choose the right reader: Opt for a sensitivity reader who has experience in your specific area of interest. Research their qualifications and read testimonials. Identify what aspects of your story would benefit most from a sensitivity read and focus your resources accordingly.

👉 Be clear about what you're searching for in a sensitivity read by providing information such as the story's genre, word count, and timeline. If your story involves potentially upsetting topics, warn the reader so they can set boundaries if necessary.

Collaborate: Remember, sensitivity readers are partners, not critics. Be willing to consider their feedback and take the time to digest their words.

Is it censorship?

The debate rages on. Sensitivity readers are declared essential for creating sensitive, respectful stories by some, while others cry foul, accusing publishers of suppressing creativity.

Frequent discussions revolve around whether sensitivity readers are tampering with already-published classics or if their real work occurs behind the scenes, helping authors craft stories that are inclusive from the ground up.

One thing is for certain: sensitivity readers are essential in ensuring that the stories we read mirroring our own experiences or those of others are culturally aware, authentic, and respectful.

🔥Always remember the goal is enhancing the story, not hindering creativity or promoting fear.

Sensitivity readers can also aid authors in the fashion-and-beauty and entertainment genres, ensuring their portrayal of diverse characters and issues are accurate and respectful, thus promoting inclusivity.
For individuals writing books on education-and-self-development and personal-growth, having a sensitivity reader can be beneficial as well, offering insights into underrepresented communities and experiences, enriching the content and broadening its appeal.
In career-development literature, sensitivity readers can provide guidance to authors who may be addressing subjects like workplace culture, discrimination, and diversity in the professional world, ensuring authenticity and enhancing the book's relevance and impact.